Data was collected from March of 2006 until November of 2008

Mart Brings Zero Jobs to Chicago

canada goose outlet nyc They don’t teach «Wal Math» in American high schools, but here’s how it works: 1 job created black friday canada goose 1 job destroyed = 1 job. canada goose outlet nyc

canada goose kensington parka uk Wal Mart has never admitted the difference between gross canada goose uk black friday jobs and net jobs. cheap Canada Goose That’s why when Wal Mart opened its only store in Chicago, Illinois on the west side, the retailer said: «This store will show what a great asset Wal Mart can Canada Goose Parka be to the community, as an employer and corporate citizen.» From Day One of Canada Goose sale its drive to locate stores in the Windy City, Wal Mart based its case on jobs. canada goose kensington parka uk

canada goose outlet germany One of Wal Mart’s most vocal apologists is Alderman Howard Brookins of the city’s 21st Ward on the South Side. «We need jobs, plain and simple,» the Alderman likes to repeat. Brookins has been so outspoken on the issue of Wal Mart and jobs that The Chicago Tribune has canada goose coats referred to him as «the Alderman from Wal Mart.» canada goose outlet germany

canada goose discount uk But the jobs argument isn’t adding up in Chicago. A new study from Loyola uk canada goose University and the canada goose coats on sale University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC) has put the giant retailer on the economic defensive once again. canada goose discount uk

canada goose outlet seattle The study, The Impact of an Urban Wal Mart Store on Area Businesses: An Evaluation of One Chicago Neighborhood’s Experience found that Wal Mart’s opening in Chicago has produced Canada Goose Jackets a loss of 300 full time canada goose clearance jobs. canada goose outlet seattle

canada goose outlet england Researchers conclude that the probability of a local retailer going out of business during the study period was significantly higher for establishments close to Wal Mart’s location. The loss of jobs in the trade area near Wal Mart just about balanced out any ‘new’ jobs attributable to Wal Mart. «These estimates support the contention that urban Wal Mart stores absorb retail sales from canada goose black friday sale other city stores without significantly expanding the market,» the researchers say. «This means that communities around the city should not see Wal Mart, and other big box retailers, as a panacea to local economic struggles.» canada goose outlet england

canada goose outlet uk sale The two universities collected data pre Wal Mart, post Wal Mart, and Canada Goose Coats On Sale post Wal Mart long term. Data was collected from March of 2006 until November of 2008. A total of 306 enterprises were tracked, and the research team found that 82 (27%)of them went out of business during the study period. canada goose outlet uk sale

canada goose outlet niagara falls A key finding of the survey is that the probability of going out of business is significantly higher for businesses close canada goose to Wal Mart. Being located close to Wal Mart was particularly toxic for retailers selling electronics, toys, office supplies, general merchandise, hardware, home furnishings, canada goose store and drugs. Apparently being near Wal Mart foot traffic did not translate into increased sales for other merchants. There is no evidence that Wal Mart sparked any significant net growth in economic activity or employment canada goose uk shop in the area.» canada goose outlet niagara falls

canada goose outlet 80 off The researchers in this new study suggest that their findings are very similar to a number of other studies on «the Wal Mart effect» that have been published since the 1980s. «Under the circumstances,» the new study says, «claims that the Chicago Wal Mart canada goose clearance sale has led to significant economic development in nearby areas must cheap canada goose uk be considered skeptically.» canada goose outlet 80 off

canada goose outlet real Wal Mart has been trying to break into the Chicago market like gangbusters since the spring of 2004 buy canada goose jacket cheap almost a six year epic struggle. The Chicago City Council responded in part to Wal Mart’s push by passing a «big box living wage» ordinance, which Chicago Mayor Richard Daley vetoed. canada goose outlet real

canada goose outlet authentic The West Canada Goose Online Side Wal Mart opened in the fall of 2006. To further enhance its chances of canada goose factory sale opening additional stores, Wal Mart announced that this West Side store was going to be part of a national campaign launched by Wal Mart called «Jobs and Opportunity Zones (JOZ).» Wal Mart promised that it would select five small local businesses for advertisements in local newspapers and on Wal Mart’s in store radio network. Wal Mart also pledged to host workshops for small businesses on how to «survive thrive» with a Wal Mart nearby. A grant of $300,000 would be donated to local chambers of commerce to create effective programs for the funds. canada goose outlet authentic

canada goose outlet website legit But researchers from Loyola and UIC interviewed 2 of the 5 businesses selected to be part of the JOZ program. Both businesses claimed that Wal Mart did buy ads for their businesses in local newspapers but neither attended any Wal Mart seminars. One owner called the Wal Mart initiative «pretty much a failure.» Instead Canada Goose Outlet of a Jobs and Opportunity Zone 27% of area businesses surveyed literally entered their final Twilight Zone. canada goose outlet website legit

canada goose outlet vancouver This new Chicago study confirms research conducted by economists Ken Stone, Tom Mueller, David Neumark, and others that reveal the dark side of Wal Mart’s canada goose uk outlet economic impacts. One earlier study showed that each Wal Mart worker replaces about 1.4 non Wal Mart retail workers. The group Retail Forward concluded in 2003 that «for every Wal Mart supercenter that opens in the next five years, two supermarkets will close their doors.» canada goose outlet vancouver

canada goose outlet black friday And what was Wal Mart’s response to this less than flattering study? According to the local ABC affiliate in Chicago, Wal Mart’s only comment was that the research was funded by «a group with ties to labor.» canada goose outlet black friday

canada goose outlet in vancouver The Loyola/UIC study should blow away any Canada Goose online notion that Wal canadian goose jacket Mart is a job generator in the Windy City. More than three years after coming buy canada goose jacket to uk canada goose outlet Chicago, Wal Mart has produced no new jobs, no new opportunities just a great big shift in market share. As Alderman Brookins might say, that’s the ‘plain and simple’ consequence of inviting Wal Mart to sit at your table. canada goose outlet in vancouver

canada goose outlet online Al Norman is the founder of Sprawl Busters. For the past 16 years he has helped hundreds of communities fight big box sprawl. His books are «Slam Dunking Wal Mart,» and «The Case Against Wal Mart.» canada goose outlet online.

Добавить комментарий

Ваш e-mail не будет опубликован. Обязательные поля помечены *